4E logo contest... | Forums

[sameer_monier]

You are spot on, people mostly voted for these two logos as far as I know.
First one seems to be a little ahead.

ah I checked it, the 1st one got heads up, and I am fine by it.

so far Variation 1 : 2215

Variation C: 2055


No other Variation seems to be able to break the 2000 mark.

I wonder which will win

[Andre202]

I do like both but the first one seems to have issues in the proportion. Like when you look at 4E how it's to big to fit in there and so it meets the edge of the circle. Or the "Fourth Echelon" itself isn't really symmetric with that circle it sourounds, you know? The second one seems to be a complete new logo, while the first one looks like they have used the original 3E logo and edited it a bit. It needs some tweeks. Not to sound picky here but you know logos are important and have to be perfect. LOL

[sameer_monier]

I do like both but the first one seems to have issues in the proportion. Like when you look at 4E how it's to big to fit in there and so it meets the edge of the circle. Or the "Fourth Echelon" itself isn't really symmetric with that circle it sourounds, you know? The second one seems to be a complete new logo, while the first one looks like they have used the original 3E logo and edited it a bit. It needs some tweeks. Not to sound picky here but you know logos are important and have to be perfect. LOL

you are totally true, tbh another thing about the first logo I don't like is the 4E style, it just feels meeeeeh to me, not cool at anyway, plus the points you mentioned, and indeed it is very important, come on now, everybody will see it, you want them to think we are not cool ?!

I like Variation C for many reasons myself, most important one is how the talon is kinda holding the earth or part of the map, gave me the feeling that 4th Echelon is watching the whole world and always prepared, but if you look at the 2 stars on the right you will see they aren't as right as the ones on the left

Whatever the wining logo is, these little problems need to be fixed, it won't take much, and add the color of course.

[SolidSage]

The Talon shield and patch are the two I voted for as well. Now someone mentioned the bird faces I see them too so the Shield is prefferable. Agree on tweaking the winner to perfect it, whichever one it is.

[RedRobin183]

Do you have to sign in to Gamespot to actually vote? I've been clicking the ones I like but it seems like it's just repeating it again and again...

[doogsy91]

Fell in love with this logo <3 Classic, fresh and memorable - beast!
Do you have the same impression that this logo is the best of all?

It's my fav.

[mateus99]

I still prefer variation C, but variation I is not bad at all its the 2nd best!

[JaRuTo]

I'm Not going to say which is better but the variation C is not distinguished by anything special, why? Graphic claw is moved from the old logo, only added a shield, changed the background and lettering around the middle of the frame have been modified.



While the Option I is a graphic mix of training deathclaw logo but much modified, that looks more natural and don't know why you can see the toe claws of birds head but if there would not be metal claw of the option C you say the same thing that you see the bird's head.
Either way, it can be a bit of tuning to make them look better but in comparison to other off much better in my opinion, and the more I look at this the more eagle also begins to like - watch below.

It seems predatory too, but more uniquely and fits into the concept of fifth freedom.

Anyway logo its not big deal form me - for now gameplay in more important than a fancy 4th Echelon's logo.

[KenTWOu]

I like these two logos. Especially the first one. Unfortunately, it seems that they aren't popular.

[The_5_Freedoms]

Actually what would have been really cool is the face of a panther staring at you head on (rather than a profile from the side).



Or a logo like the Third Echelon one except instead of an eagle claw it's a panther paw.