I know this has been discussed many times before, but still- I think the people who thought AC 2's graphics were cartoonish just didn't understand the graphics style. They definately weren't "cartoonish" if you understood it.
I mean, brotherhood is better on detail in the texture work, but this is mitigated by that wierd shadow filter on the robes that makes it all speckled and weird. Lighting definately goes to AC 2.
If brotherhood had AC 2's style of character model lighting/rendering on top of brotherhood's textures, I think people would see that brotherhood wouldn't have looked a LOT better. Plus the weird shadowing in acb wouldn't be a problem either.
Idk am I the only one who gets this? I wish I could post a video or something to help explain.