Which one is more successful in their attack role? What do you think?
Lately I've been playing IL-2 campaign and I can't but to notice that IL-2's guns especially in mid-variants and some later variants simply rocks... VyA-23 and NS-23/30 are kick-arse cannons... will kill many things on ground.
IL-2 also has great anti-tank rocket arsenal... possible to destroy several tanks with it.
On the other hand, Ju-87 is perhaps on of the best (if not the best) attack aircraft in anti shipping role... very versatile and useful in any kind of very precise, pinpoint bombing where you have to drop enormous bomb load at one spot.
All things considered I give advantage to IL-2.
How about you?