ubi.com    Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Might and Magic  Hop To Forums  Dark Messiah Might and Magic General Discussion    Why do they all have to ruin it?
Page 1 2 3 4 5 

Moderators: FCY-JMDK-WLKY, Mana_SG
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
  Login/Join 
Posted
Why is it that all the game companies today have to take classic RPG games and ruin them with FPS. Why cant we just have the good ole RPGs of yester yore. Those are the games that we always talk about for years and years, not these crappy action versions. Why does every game company have to screw with this? Why keep trying to re-invent the wheel? Its obvious what people want, cant you just give it to them? Look at the polls, traditional RPGs man. Thats what M&M is all about.
 
Posts: 2 | Registered: Mon March 13 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of MMihnea
Posted Hide Post
That's exactly what i said before .
And others before me .
But is ok to say it again.
And again.
Maybe like this they will understand .
Maybe.
 
Posts: 124 | Registered: Mon August 08 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of CountJorg
Posted Hide Post
maybe your just that narrow minded that you cant see how awesome this will be. that in using the source engine this isnt just a fps this is will be a great game with a idea on combat styles. and why would you just a message board just to tell everyone how bad you think something will be when you havent even played the game yet. lrn2enjoygames

This message has been edited. Last edited by: FCY-JMDK-WLKY,
 
Posts: 8 | Registered: Sun March 26 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Global Moderator
Picture of FCY-JMDK-WLKY
Posted Hide Post
Watch you language CountJorg, these forums are rated E.


______________________________
Soup, soup, a tasty soup, soup, a spicy Carrot and Coriander, Chili Chowder, crouton, crouton, crunchy friends in a liquid broth
I am gazpacho - ho - I am a summer soup - ho - Miso Miso, fighting in the dojo, Miso Miso, oriental prince in the land of soup
 
Posts: 13309 | Registered: Sat November 20 2004Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of CountJorg
Posted Hide Post
sorry admin people who bash games they havent even seen really get to me. have you seen the purepwnage eps? i was just quoting. lol good times
 
Posts: 8 | Registered: Sun March 26 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Global Moderator
Picture of FCY-JMDK-WLKY
Posted Hide Post
Well you make a good point, but you have to keep in mind that the Might and Magic frenchise has a large gathering of fans from the previous games and they were probably expecting a game similar to those 3DO/New World Computing made before they went bankrupt. It's natural they'll feel disappointed when they see the game's not going that way at all.
But it can be a good game even if it's not what the older fans expected of course.

And no, can't say I've seen them. I just can't allow swearing here because there are a lot of minors (many even younger than 13) on the boards and the content on them should be appropriate for all those ages.


______________________________
Soup, soup, a tasty soup, soup, a spicy Carrot and Coriander, Chili Chowder, crouton, crouton, crunchy friends in a liquid broth
I am gazpacho - ho - I am a summer soup - ho - Miso Miso, fighting in the dojo, Miso Miso, oriental prince in the land of soup
 
Posts: 13309 | Registered: Sat November 20 2004Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of MMihnea
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by CountJorg:
maybe your just that narrow minded that you cant see how awesome this will be. that in using the source engine this isnt just a fps this is will be a great game with a idea on combat styles. and why would you just a message board just to tell everyone how bad you think something will be when you havent even played the game yet. lrn2enjoygames

a discussion with you is pointles
first of all you should read the description of the game( the official one )
then you shoul read the posts and try to understand what those people meant
 
Posts: 124 | Registered: Mon August 08 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Justice
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by oxlar:
Why is it that all the game companies today have to take classic RPG games and ruin them with FPS. Why cant we just have the good ole RPGs of yester yore. Those are the games that we always talk about for years and years, not these crappy action versions. Why does every game company have to screw with this? Why keep trying to re-invent the wheel? Its obvious what people want, cant you just give it to them? Look at the polls, traditional RPGs man. Thats what M&M is all about.


QFE... can't be said often enough.


I see you - when I turn away
I hold you -when my hands are full
I kiss you - when you aren't here
- Freedom -
Never shall you be more than a name to me
 
Posts: 7041 | Registered: Fri April 01 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by oxlar:
Why is it that all the game companies today have to take classic RPG games and ruin them with FPS. Why cant we just have the good ole RPGs of yester yore. Those are the games that we always talk about for years and years, not these crappy action versions. Why does every game company have to screw with this? Why keep trying to re-invent the wheel? Its obvious what people want, cant you just give it to them? Look at the polls, traditional RPGs man. Thats what M&M is all about.


By my knowledge there IS a more traditional M&M game coming out. It just isn't Dark Messiah. From all of the previews I've seen, Dark Messiah isn't your typical RPG with a first person view. DM looks to be far more action based, and the one game I feel comfortable comparing a *fraction* of the gameplay to is Thief.

This game is likely to be of the kind that's talked about and played for years after the fact. Just by the way the singleplayer game and the multiplayer mode is being setup. Lets be honest now. With the flood of "classic" RPG's that we've seen in the last 5 years how many do you suspect we'll really be "talking about for years to come".

It should also be noted that back in the day, PC RPG's were traditionally first person. Take a look at Betrayal at Krondor. It's easily one of the first and best RPG's of all time and it's a first person rpg. It's also released as freeware, so look it up.
 
Posts: 7 | Registered: Mon March 27 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
I still can't get into my head why this title uses the name of might and magic, when it is closer to the elder scrolls series.
Surely this game, (as good as it looks don't get me wrong it WILL be on preorder!!!), would be better called Elder Scrolls 5: The Dark Messiah, rather than dark Messiah of Might and Magic.
Stu.
 
Posts: 32 | Registered: Mon August 22 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Sir_Grockalot:
I still can't get into my head why this title uses the name of might and magic, when it is closer to the elder scrolls series.
Surely this game, (as good as it looks don't get me wrong it WILL be on preorder!!!), would be better called Elder Scrolls 5: The Dark Messiah, rather than dark Messiah of Might and Magic.
Stu.


Ubisoft, or whoever is in charge of the M&M franchine now decided to redesign the M&M world. Since Dark Messiah is set in that world, it is titled as a M&M game, even though it isn't a traditional M&M game.

(And I still say that Dark Messiah is more like Thief than the Elder Scrolls games.)
 
Posts: 7 | Registered: Mon March 27 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
No offense, but some of you have a REALLY daunting ability to say some extremely stupid things.

Thankfully I don't have the time, nor the drive to point them all out.

And hey, I have a genius idea? Don't like this genre of game? Don't like the look of this game?
then JUST DON'T BUY IT. Oh my god, thinking of THAT was sure hard.
 
Posts: 1 | Registered: Sat March 25 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Justice
Posted Hide Post
The problem is simply the name... why call it Might and Magic and cheat thousands into buying it because they don't know it has nothing to do with Might and Magic, except the name.


I see you - when I turn away
I hold you -when my hands are full
I kiss you - when you aren't here
- Freedom -
Never shall you be more than a name to me
 
Posts: 7041 | Registered: Fri April 01 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Secret_Holder
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Sir_Grockalot:
I still can't get into my head why this title uses the name of might and magic, when it is closer to the elder scrolls series.
Surely this game, (as good as it looks don't get me wrong it WILL be on preorder!!!), would be better called Elder Scrolls 5: The Dark Messiah, rather than dark Messiah of Might and Magic.


Well, the proper term for such games is a "spin-off". MM has had quite a lot of those.

  • Heroes of Might and Magic
  • Crusaders Of Might and Magic
  • Legends of Might and Magic
  • Swords of XEEN
  • Warriors of Might and Magic
  • Dark Messiah of Might and Magic
  • Heroes Chronicles


    The great nations have always acted like gangsters, and the small nations like prostitutes - Stanley Kubrick
  •  
    Posts: 1289 | Registered: Sat April 30 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
    Posted Hide Post
    That's perfectly logical, Secret_Holder, and the M&M hardcore know it to be true and are well aware that the M&M series may well be getting a good action-based spin-off at last (unlike the poor Legends and Crusaders), but to acknowledge this fact would mean they have nothing to whinge about.

    And these people love to whine and twist and complain.

    Arkane's previous game, Arx Fatalis, had an excellent community on its publisher's forums, but sadly it looks like this one is to be plagued by illogical, petulant bleating for eternity. These are the same threads that have been appearing since first word of the game came out last year. It would be nice if those who have no interest in the game would just butt out and leave those of us who are looking forward to it to enjoy the forums, but it's not going to happen, even after the game is released. It seems "why do they all have to ruin it?" is a pertinenet question after all.

    Even though I know it's utterly futile, I'll repeat what I've already said countless times:

    • This isn't a main M&M game, and NOBODY EVER SAID IT WOULD BE. It's a spin-off, it has been described as such from the very beginning, and at last it looks like you might be getting a damn good one. Oh, you poor, hard-done-by creatures.
    • NOBODY is being cheated. If you're stupid enough to blindly buy a game without checking first to see whether you'll like it, that's your own fault. Smarten up. If you have some completist's compulsion to buy every game with an M&M tag, you know that you'll be buying spin-offs, and you know this means you're committing yourself to buying games you may not like. Take responsibilty for your own actions - blaming someone else for your inability to make an intelligent, informed purchase is utterly sickening. And whaddya know, if that's your stance then you've already "been cheated" (or truthfully: cheated yourself) by forcing yourself to buy M&M 8... and 9.... and Legends... and Crusaders... etc. even though they were garbage. Yet you have the gall to call what looks to be the first superb M&M spin-off a con. You should be ashamed of yourselves.
    • You're making a constructive, enjoyable community of those who like Arkane and the kind of design they stand for (a legacy of the games of Looking Glass, undisputably one of the best PC games developers that ever existed) an absolute impossibility. Is that why you come to these forums? Is your sole purpose here to make things difficult and annoying for people with different opinions to your own? Yes, I'm aware you all wanted a M&M10 but YOU'VE KNOWN ALL ALONG that this game would not be it, and yet you've been kicking up the same stink for months. Why are you ruining it for us?



    Has any of this sunk in yet? No, thought not.
     
    Posts: 24 | Registered: Tue March 28 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
    Picture of Dergos
    Posted Hide Post
    Agree
    piln i'm sorry you have to see this but they are having the same reaction as i did when i first came here, i expected a real mm-rpg, but it turned out to be an fps 'kinda thing', so when i saw that i was really frustrated, but in time i learned to deal with it and so will they i guess after some time to get used to the concept.


    ************************************************


    ()_() .(\__/)
    ( x_x) (+'.'+)
    ((")(") ('')_('')
     
    Posts: 1580 | Registered: Tue September 13 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
    Posted Hide Post
    Well... thanks Smile I understand what you're saying and, yes, I can understand the disappointment to some extent.

    But I won't turn a blind eye to kneejerk expressions of that disappointment that are nothing more than poorly-researched flamebait,(the OP calls Dark Messiah a "crappy action version," which indicates a complete lack of knowledge of the project, or even of opinions on this forum). And nor will I tolerate outright lies, such as the accusation that Ubisoft are somehow tricking M&M fans into buying this game. This is nothing but trolling - if you people truly do not intend to provoke argument, then please think and do some research before you post.

    And be aware that on any forum, it is bad form to create a new thread on a topic that has already been discussed dozens of times.
     
    Posts: 24 | Registered: Tue March 28 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
    Picture of Secret_Holder
    Posted Hide Post
    quote:
    Originally posted by piln:
    That's perfectly logical, Secret_Holder, and the M&M hardcore know it to be true and are well aware that the M&M series may well be getting a good action-based spin-off at last (unlike the poor Legends and Crusaders), but to acknowledge this fact would mean they have nothing to whinge about.

    And these people love to whine and twist and complain.

    Arkane's previous game, Arx Fatalis, had an excellent community on its publisher's forums, but sadly it looks like this one is to be plagued by illogical, petulant bleating for eternity. These are the same threads that have been appearing since first word of the game came out last year. It would be nice if those who have no interest in the game would just butt out and leave those of us who are looking forward to it to enjoy the forums, but it's not going to happen, even after the game is released. It seems "why do they all have to ruin it?" is a pertinenet question after all.

    Even though I know it's utterly futile, I'll repeat what I've already said countless times:

    • This isn't a main M&M game, and NOBODY EVER SAID IT WOULD BE. It's a spin-off, it has been described as such from the very beginning, and at last it looks like you might be getting a damn good one. Oh, you poor, hard-done-by creatures.
    • NOBODY is being cheated. If you're stupid enough to blindly buy a game without checking first to see whether you'll like it, that's your own fault. Smarten up. If you have some completist's compulsion to buy every game with an M&M tag, you know that you'll be buying spin-offs, and you know this means you're committing yourself to buying games you may not like. Take responsibilty for your own actions - blaming someone else for your inability to make an intelligent, informed purchase is utterly sickening. And whaddya know, if that's your stance then you've already "been cheated" (or truthfully: cheated yourself) by forcing yourself to buy M&M 8... and 9.... and Legends... and Crusaders... etc. even though they were garbage. Yet you have the gall to call what looks to be the first superb M&M spin-off a con. You should be ashamed of yourselves.
    • You're making a constructive, enjoyable community of those who like Arkane and the kind of design they stand for (a legacy of the games of Looking Glass, undisputably one of the best PC games developers that ever existed) an absolute impossibility. Is that why you come to these forums? Is your sole purpose here to make things difficult and annoying for people with different opinions to your own? Yes, I'm aware you all wanted a M&M10 but YOU'VE KNOWN ALL ALONG that this game would not be it, and yet you've been kicking up the same stink for months. Why are you ruining it for us?



    Has any of this sunk in yet? No, thought not.


    Agree
    Excactly! It's a spin-off and a damn good one by the looks of it.
    But I hope this story will fit in with HoMM5 and the maybe-soon-to-come MMX. That would give all these games the kind of "spark" or "charm" that the old MM and spin-offs had.


    The great nations have always acted like gangsters, and the small nations like prostitutes - Stanley Kubrick
     
    Posts: 1289 | Registered: Sat April 30 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
    Picture of Justice
    Posted Hide Post
    I pretyy much agree Piln, excepto n point two... it aren't only those who want to play who buy the games, there are things like presents and such... grandparents and the such aren't exactly known for being the best with PCs and the like... And untill now it has only been Legends that difeer a bit from the taste of most MM fans, and that isn't the most fameous game, so it isn't before now the may discover that this MM isn't anything like MM... But hey, they might be nice enough to make it perfectly clear just how different this is, if that is the case it'll be one of the first times I see that...

    And I also reserve myself the right to whine untill MM X comes Shady


    I see you - when I turn away
    I hold you -when my hands are full
    I kiss you - when you aren't here
    - Freedom -
    Never shall you be more than a name to me
     
    Posts: 7041 | Registered: Fri April 01 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
    Picture of CountJorg
    Posted Hide Post
    Even though i haven't played the m&m games in the past and i have only seen my friends playing heros 3. i still think you all should have a more open mind about games there titles and that the company that makes them dont change the games style to make poepl mad at them but only in what they think would please the largest croud. and me being a new fan of this up and coming game i think they have made a bold move and i think because im telling you about it that there marketing is working. maybe they need a new fan base and ive been waiting a long time to join this one.
     
    Posts: 8 | Registered: Sun March 26 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
      Powered by Eve Community Page 1 2 3 4 5  
     

    ubi.com    Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Might and Magic  Hop To Forums  Dark Messiah Might and Magic General Discussion    Why do they all have to ruin it?

    Terms of Use

    Privacy Policy