|
Go
![]() |
New
![]() |
Find
![]() |
Notify
![]() |
Tools
![]() |
Reply
![]() |
|
Far Cry moderator![]() |
Please, let's not bring the US Civil War into this thread, that argument alone could fill up an entire thread, and we'd probably wind up with a few people getting banned.
Back on topic - there isn't going to be any "genocide" in Iran. Genocide is a very specific term, where one group of people targets an another entire group of people, usually on ethnic or religious grounds. WWII under Hitler was genocide. Cambodia was genocide. Rwanda was genocide. Darfur is genocide. What's happening in Iran is a brutal, bloody crackdown, but nothing even close to what genocide is. A better comparison would be that Iran could become a police state like the former East Germany or any of the former Iron Curtain countries. |
|||
|
I think its very hard for anyone to commit genocide without the world knowing these days.
Yea but unlike 1940s, we aren't being pressured by any country to intervene. |
||||
|
|
|
If you want to get really technical, S.Korea remained its own country, so that worked out decent enough, if not as well as some could have hoped for. Quite frankly, I have no faith in the U.N. to make rational decisions at this point, since all the powerful countries try to manipulate it for their own gains at the expense of others. I would be just as happy as with a direct agreement between--say--NATO and a few of the other major powers (along with any countries in the area,) to intervene if the situation turned into attempted genocide (you know, the thing that failed to happen during all of the conflicts Brim mentioned.) You're right, it is all because of America's need for oil. But let's not forget protecting American interests is just as important as protecting America. Losing our streams of oil from Venezuela and the Gulf would cripple the U.S.'s ability to defend its home borders. So, and I know some people are going to disagree with me on this, defending America's oil interests with force really is the a sound strategy until we can drill our own oil. Or even better, wean ourselves off of it. Do I hear fusion power and electric cars? But I digress. The U.S. is now paying for the policies it carried out in the past. Hopefully it will convince the President to handle Iran in a better way: i.e., do nothing unless things get so out of hand it could destabilize the whole region. And then, they should only act with the many other countries who have interests in the region. Which, so far, appears to be Obama's plan. So we'll see. |
|||
|
|
|
We always feel the sting of our interferance in other peoples business.
Bin Laden. Saddam Hussein. Manuel Noriega. I could keep going, but this would be a long list. Iran's problem is that the Theocracy is trying to stop any dissent. None of the other Arab countries are Theocracies. This is a major reason why the Arabs among other would like us to sit right between them and Iran. Iran is steadily trying to spread their influence around the region. Their close ties with Syria. The fact that Hezbollah now has people on the governing parliament in Lebanon. And then of course there is the plight of the Palestinians. Now keep in mind, that in reality the Palestinians are basically outcast Syrians who squatted on the land they occupy. They not only never had Syrians permission to occupy that region which actually belonged to them It is all because of of the PLO whose Leader Yassar Arafat we also supported and even recognized as a world leader. Obama and every other politition would love to see the Iranians rise up and overthrow the Theocracy all together. If the people stand strong and can find a way to communicate, they could plan a coup. We need to stay out of this one. Let it run its course and then step in when the moment is right. North Korea is an issue that needs to be addressed soon. They are out of control and unstable as a nation with all of the poverty for Military buildup. Once junior gets in there we need to watch out because i bet as soon as Kim Sr. croaks the son will want to honor him and launch a surprise strike to let the world know whats up. We have our hands in to many cookie jars at the moment and our own is currently in need of our attention. We need to fix our own issues before we tell everyone else that they are doing it wrong. Hubris and posturing never do more than distract. Regarding the Civil War, which gets updated and rewritten every few years BTW. The 9% mentioned earlier all happened to be Plantation Owners. They were among the richest men in the country at that time. Washington relied on them for all sorts of support for infrastructure. Senators were in the pockets of these men. Basically these men were very powerful in the country. So when word gets out that Lincoln is planning to free the Slaves, Well that doesn't go over to well. So Many southern governors threaten cessation to form their own country so they can have their own Federal laws. Which would have included a right to own slave labor. Rich men did not want to see their money going out of their pockets to pay people. Also back in those days, one Million dollars was akin to about 1.5 Billion today. A lot of honorable men faught and died for North and South All pawns for the gain of a Few. Just like most things are done still today. |
|||
|
![]() |
I have been following perisankiwi on twitter for a few weeks. Its disturbing to have not heard from them since Wednesday. This monumental Iran situation is hearbreaking to say the least. Its imperative that people take the time to inform themselves on the issue. Im glad that you shared that information Josh. I hadnt seen one of those videos yet, thanks for posting them.
I dont think that anyone else other than the people of Iran can make things right. I wish we could help, but I dont think it would do any good. I agree with myxoteque, if we offer our aid right now it would really take away from the protesters when they win. If the government breaks the social contract, its up to the people to revolt. There is nothing more powerful than the people, and their future wont be bleak as long as the Iranians remember that and continue to fight. |
|||
|
![]() |
Well said, Zee. I couldn't have put it better myself.
It's very important for us to realize that our past interventions, which almost always had a hidden agenda to them, have come to bite us in the *** a couple decades later. We need to stop being Team America, World Police. Thanks to Phin for the sig! Live GT: l337pino Steam ID: 1337pino |
|||
|
![]() |
Fo sho |
|||
|
![]() |
WARNING: Wall of text ahead
SOURCE
|
|||
|
![]() |
As sad as that story is, Im sure that the people imprisoned in Iran right now would trade what they are going through for Ali's experience. I highly doubt that anyone who doesnt have any information will be just let go and on parole this time around. At least Ali escaped with his life, how many people are going to have that luxury when this is all said and done.
|
|||
|
![]() |
Nobody is asking for our help and Iranians really, for the most part, don't seem to harbor any hatred for the american people. It might be the theocracy's stance to blame all their worries on the great satan but the common people mostly know it's a bunch of malarchy. They're very westernised, most speak english. As in america, it's mostly the uneducated, insular masses who believe the worst government lies and take the hawkish stance, but their numbers have been shrinking as education spreads, the old generation dies off and access to the internet increases. Even if nothing comes of the current protests, something will from protests eventually as the number of people who want a change increases. These protests are much larger than the ones from 1991 and those protests were only students, these are across the board.
Question Mark, they're all iranians. This isn't going to turn into genocide even if it became a shooting war. Which it isn't currently. It's an idealogical conflict. It's too simple of an idea to say Musavi good, Amnijinidad bad. The people protesting are certainly the heroes of the story, but if it's not like Musavi wants it to come to shooting as a favorite of the Ayatola. And if people started shooting in his name would there really be a point? It would certainly be nice if the government could be toppled bloodlessly. Or if a revote was taken and overseen by say the UN. If everything was really above the board, why not? "I often quote myself. It adds spice to my conversation." --George Bernard Shaw |
|||
|
![]() |
Word from some of the other Twitters from inside Iran is that Persiankiwi is ok and will be back once a safe internet connection can be found. A first-hand account of the raids on the University of Tehran dorms:
|
|||
|
![]() |
About a week ago, 8 employees of the British embassy in Tehran were arrested by the Iranian government. You can read about that here: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories...ld/main5119484.shtml
The more troublesome news now is that, while some of those employees have been released, others are reportedly set to stand trail in Iran for their supposed roles in post-election protests. More than anything, it just seems like another move by Ahmadinejad to blame and punish the West for the current state Iran is in. One could assume a more aggressive stance will be taken by the UK and their allies as a result. |
|||
|
| Powered by Eve Community | Page 1 2 |
| Please Wait. Your request is being processed... |
|

