ubi.com    Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  1C:Maddox Games  Hop To Forums  IL2 Maddox General Discussion    ok, help me learn Complex Engine Management
Page 1 2 3 
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
  Login/Join 
Picture of crucislancer
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by TinyTim:
On the CSP (constant speed propeller) equipped planes you shouldn't overrev no matter how fast you go. The job of CSP is to constantly adjust the pitch of the propeller blades so that your engine stays at constant RPM. You can overrev planes without CSP in a dive (like Gladiator, P.11 and similar), or the ones where you can disengage CSP.


I'm quite certain you can overrev a Tempest in a dive, but I never actually tested it. I recall a few times going into a dive with everything full on + boost, and it sounded like the engine was going to explode any second. I yanked back PP and shut off boost and it mellowed out, but sometimes I'm left with a rough engine after that. I'll play with it tonight and see what happens.


------------------------------
Flying online as "johnnybassman" / X52 profile for IL-2 1946

My Band

 
Posts: 2174 | Registered: Tue March 06 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Skunk_438RCAF
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by TinyTim:
On the CSP (constant speed propeller) equipped planes you shouldn't overrev no matter how fast you go. The job of CSP is to constantly adjust the pitch of the propeller blades so that your engine stays at constant RPM. You can overrev planes without CSP in a dive (like Gladiator, P.11 and similar), or the ones where you can disengage CSP.


I doubt its modelled, but you can overrev a CSP...the governor just has to fail.
 
Posts: 761 | Registered: Fri June 08 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by TinyTim:
On the CSP (constant speed propeller) equipped planes you shouldn't overrev no matter how fast you go. The job of CSP is to constantly adjust the pitch of the propeller blades so that your engine stays at constant RPM. You can overrev planes without CSP in a dive (like Gladiator, P.11 and similar), or the ones where you can disengage CSP.


CSP's ability to adjust RPM has a limit.


----------------
Flying online as nate85
"I can buy a scalpel, that doesn't make me a surgeon." - M_Gunz
 
Posts: 1505 | Registered: Sun February 11 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of TinyTim
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by na85:
quote:
Originally posted by TinyTim:
On the CSP (constant speed propeller) equipped planes you shouldn't overrev no matter how fast you go. The job of CSP is to constantly adjust the pitch of the propeller blades so that your engine stays at constant RPM. You can overrev planes without CSP in a dive (like Gladiator, P.11 and similar), or the ones where you can disengage CSP.


CSP's ability to adjust RPM has a limit.


In real life sure, but is this limit modelled in IL-2?


No one in sane mind ever turns when he has any other option.
~ DKoor
 
Posts: 1262 | Registered: Thu December 06 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by TinyTim:
quote:
Originally posted by na85:
quote:
Originally posted by TinyTim:
On the CSP (constant speed propeller) equipped planes you shouldn't overrev no matter how fast you go. The job of CSP is to constantly adjust the pitch of the propeller blades so that your engine stays at constant RPM. You can overrev planes without CSP in a dive (like Gladiator, P.11 and similar), or the ones where you can disengage CSP.


CSP's ability to adjust RPM has a limit.


In real life sure, but is this limit modelled in IL-2?


Pretty sure.

I do know that you can over-rev a 190 in a dive.


----------------
Flying online as nate85
"I can buy a scalpel, that doesn't make me a surgeon." - M_Gunz
 
Posts: 1505 | Registered: Sun February 11 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of TinyTim
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by na85:
quote:
Originally posted by TinyTim:
quote:
Originally posted by na85:
quote:
Originally posted by TinyTim:
On the CSP (constant speed propeller) equipped planes you shouldn't overrev no matter how fast you go. The job of CSP is to constantly adjust the pitch of the propeller blades so that your engine stays at constant RPM. You can overrev planes without CSP in a dive (like Gladiator, P.11 and similar), or the ones where you can disengage CSP.


CSP's ability to adjust RPM has a limit.


In real life sure, but is this limit modelled in IL-2?


Pretty sure.

I do know that you can over-rev a 190 in a dive.


Yeah, in 190 you can, if you disengage auto pitch. Doubt you can however if you don't.


No one in sane mind ever turns when he has any other option.
~ DKoor
 
Posts: 1262 | Registered: Thu December 06 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
Correct, I forgot to mention manual mode. But IIRC the 190 in manual mode functions just like a CSP does it not?


----------------
Flying online as nate85
"I can buy a scalpel, that doesn't make me a surgeon." - M_Gunz
 
Posts: 1505 | Registered: Sun February 11 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Kettenhunde
Posted Hide Post
quote:
On the CSP (constant speed propeller) equipped planes you shouldn't overrev no matter how fast you go.


You can over rev a CSP AND you can over boost the manifold pressure with a CSP.

When you maneuver, you must adjust the manifold pressure to keep it within tolerance for the engine.

Additionally, the CSP rpm is adjusted both at the cable, governor, and propeller itself. It is very common to adjust them at then come out on a different day to find your rpm/manifold relationship is not the same due to density altitude.

Generally speaking, only on a day similar to the one the propeller/engine was adjusted will you find the performance stated in the manual.

I once owned an airplane that required annual in June. Every winter, I would notice a 100-150rpm decrease at full throttle for example.

All the best,

Crumpp



Our Museum glorifies no state, but strives to use these aircraft as a memorial for all lost in war. Our freedom can only be truly appreciated when held in contrast to those who sought to destroy it. Our staff is proudly made up of people from many cultures and religions. Click the photos for details of our projects.
"Those who do not remember history are destined to repeat it." - Winston Churchill
 
Posts: 3068 | Registered: Fri March 25 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Kettenhunde
Posted Hide Post
quote:
But IIRC the 190 in manual mode functions just like a CSP does it not?


In RL no.
The VDM propellers have two settings, Automatic and Emergency.
In automatic, the VDM hydraulic electric propellers function as a CSP. In emergency, they function as an adjustable pitch. The pilot must adjust the pitch to reach the required rpm for the manifold pressure using "recipe" flying.

All the best,

Crumpp



Our Museum glorifies no state, but strives to use these aircraft as a memorial for all lost in war. Our freedom can only be truly appreciated when held in contrast to those who sought to destroy it. Our staff is proudly made up of people from many cultures and religions. Click the photos for details of our projects.
"Those who do not remember history are destined to repeat it." - Winston Churchill
 
Posts: 3068 | Registered: Fri March 25 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Kettenhunde:
quote:
But IIRC the 190 in manual mode functions just like a CSP does it not?


In RL no.


Yeah, I meant in0game Smile

From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constant_speed_propeller

quote:
oil is pumped through the propeller shaft to push on a piston which drives the mechanism to change pitch. The flow of oil and the pitch is controlled by a governor. The constant-speed propeller also has a speeder spring, fly weights, and a pilot valve. The tension of the speeder spring is set by the prop control lever, which sets the RPMs.


The above seems to me to be pretty much what we have ingame when the 190 operates on manual pitch.


----------------
Flying online as nate85
"I can buy a scalpel, that doesn't make me a surgeon." - M_Gunz
 
Posts: 1505 | Registered: Sun February 11 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Kettenhunde
Posted Hide Post
quote:
The above seems to me to be pretty much what we have ingame when the 190 operates on manual pitch.


It is not correctly modeled then in your game.

The only "manual" on the FW-190 is the Emergency setting. This system is not designed for combat or cross country flight. It is an emergency setting so the pilot can safely land the aircraft for repairs. The manifold pressure is severly limited.

All the best,

Crumpp



Our Museum glorifies no state, but strives to use these aircraft as a memorial for all lost in war. Our freedom can only be truly appreciated when held in contrast to those who sought to destroy it. Our staff is proudly made up of people from many cultures and religions. Click the photos for details of our projects.
"Those who do not remember history are destined to repeat it." - Winston Churchill
 
Posts: 3068 | Registered: Fri March 25 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of crucislancer
Posted Hide Post
So, I tested the Tempest to see if I could overrev the engine, I started a dive from 16,000 feet, everything all the way up with Boost on, and it didn't overrev. It sounded like it would, but my ailerons came off before it could happen. Maybe a different plane might work for that test, but the Tempest has some great acceleration in a dive.

quote:
Originally posted by Skunk_438RCAF:
I doubt its modelled, but you can overrev a CSP...the governor just has to fail.


This is true, though, and this is modeled in the game, at least with the Tempest and Spitfire. It's happened quite a bit with both, but no other planes that I'm aware of. Many times I've nursed one of those two planes back to base with the PP and throttle set low just to keep the engine from running off.


------------------------------
Flying online as "johnnybassman" / X52 profile for IL-2 1946

My Band

 
Posts: 2174 | Registered: Tue March 06 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Kettenhunde
Posted Hide Post
quote:
but you can overrev a CSP...the governor just has to fail.


In RL, the governor does not have to fail. The blades just have to reach the stops.

The propeller then begins driving the engine and your manifold pressure will begin to increase. If it increases too much, the engine will be damaged.

All the best,

Crumpp



Our Museum glorifies no state, but strives to use these aircraft as a memorial for all lost in war. Our freedom can only be truly appreciated when held in contrast to those who sought to destroy it. Our staff is proudly made up of people from many cultures and religions. Click the photos for details of our projects.
"Those who do not remember history are destined to repeat it." - Winston Churchill
 
Posts: 3068 | Registered: Fri March 25 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
We don't have shock-cooling from enormous dives, we don't have the prop gears tearing apart when given massive strain....

So much of what we don't have is because less than 20 frames per second is even less acceptable then getting exceptional
circumstances aircraft behavior just so.


When people take a plane out to see what it can do they really find what they can do with it.

 
Posts: 6725 | Registered: Tue March 06 2007Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
I've tried adjusting the supercharger in a P-47, and nothing happens. If you have the key mapped, and it doesn't seem to be working, is there another problem?
 
Posts: 142 | Registered: Sun March 27 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
I believe the supercharger is automatic on the P-47.


Good hunting,
Sillius_Sodus
 
Posts: 919 | Registered: Fri September 16 2005Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
  Powered by Eve Community Page 1 2 3  
 

ubi.com    Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  1C:Maddox Games  Hop To Forums  IL2 Maddox General Discussion    ok, help me learn Complex Engine Management

Terms of Use

Privacy Policy